Quantcast

Defamer Talks To The Razzies Founder About The Shocking 'Spirit' Snub [Defamer Interviews]

defamer.com - 8th Jan 2009

1 votes
Tom Cruise: How, we wondered yesterday, could the Razzies have overlooked the tailor-made star bombThe Spirit for inclusion on their annual dishonor roll of nominees? We went straight to Razzies founder John Wilson for the scoop.DEFAMER: So the nominees that emerged yesterday weren't official yet? JOHN: What happened is we have press members on our mailing list, and this guy Larry Carroll from MTV's Movie Blog apparently misunderstood and thought that was a final list. And it kind of went viral for us.So what was it, if not a list of nominees? When we send out our nominating ballots, we also send out a list of suggested nominees—only because if you don't steer it somehow, you just get no consensus with as many people as we have voting. Those are likely nominees when the final ballots are tabulated and the actual nominations are announced on the 21st, but those are not the official nominees. newVideoPlayer("/spirit_consid.flv", 506, 423,""); Are there any dark horses that could still emerge? I'm assuming you're talking about The Spirit, which is getting a lot of write-in votes. One of the things that's happened ever since the Oscars jumped their show a month ahead is that we have to get our material out the week of Christmas, and anything that comes out on Christmas or later is not likely to make it out onto our ballot. [...] With Tom Cruise (in the Christmas-released Valkyrie), someone asked, "Well, how can Tom Cruise be on there if The Spirit wasn't?" And with Tom Cruise, the advance buzz was really awful. Although apparently the movie isn't that bad, so it'll be interesting to see if he does or does not get a nomination.Well, one big star vehicle that seems to have supplanted Valkyrie as far as public ire is Seven Pounds, which a poll of critics recently voted the year's worst. You know, I've seen that. It's weird, and it's an odd concept for a movie, but it's not quite to the standards of what we would consider for a Razzie. At least until the jellyfish part, which definitely belongs on the "nuke the fridge" list. Up to that point, it's a reasonably reputable movie, though I should admit that it also is getting write-in votes for screenplay. I don't think Will Smith is getting many votes for that, he's getting them for Hancock.So what criteria do you consider for Worst Picture? We look at box office—and big box office doesn't protect you from being Razzie-nominated—we look at the Tomatometer on Rotten Tomatoes, we pay attention to what's being said on the forum of our website. We look at the track record of the people involved. Like Uwe Boll—the guy over at Rope of Silicon was saying "duh." Well yeah, "duh"—it's the same thing as Meryl Streep getting an Oscar nomination! Uwe Boll is just as shitty a director as Meryl Streep is a terrific actress. They're kind of mirrors of one another, and nobody attacks the Academy for nominating Meryl Streep. Uwe's Boll's Postal...if you've seen it, you have my sympathies. I actually have, and it's right up there with Freddy Got Fingered as just an inexcusable, tasteless, unfunny, "why did anyone give this person money" movie. And Freddy Got Fingered is the only Worst Picture winner that I've actually hated.Has there ever been any overlap with Oscar bait? One of our editors suggested Revolutionary Road this year... Three times, I believe, the exact same thing has been nominated for a Razzie and an Oscar. And in all three cases, it didn't win either. The best known one is probably Amy Irving as Barbra Streisand's wife in Yentl, who was nominated as both Best and Worst Supporting Actress. I'm trying to remember if the song from Con Air, "How Do I Live," that also may have been nominated for both.Well there are so many terrible Oscar-nominated songs! That's probably the category that deserves the most overlap. We actually had a Worst Song category for years, and we had a lot of fun with it. Generally speaking, though, if a song gets a Razzie nomination it's probably one that won't get played a lot on the radio. Although I guess "I Want Your Sex" from Beverly Hills Cop II did win a Razzie!So what do you think are the top frontrunners this year? I don't think I agree with our members or the public about The Love Guru. I thought that it was stupid, but I didn't find it offensive. Still, it looks like it has the inside track to get nominated all over the place. I know that when this list went viral yesterday, a lot of the public was disturbed that we had bothered to nominate Rambo. Personally, I think Rambo was a violent, pointless, ill-conceived, badly-written, horribly-acted, badly-edited piece of crap.Tell us how you really feel! Eddie Murphy has the highest-profile box office bomb of the year in Meet Dave. I Will be curious to see how many nominations—not if it Will get nominated, but how many—it Will get. He swept three characters at last year's awards, so I'm sure he'll end up with some. The one I'm hoping gets a lot of nominations is Postal. The real enigma about Uwe Boll is not why he exists but why he continues to make movies! Who needs the tax loss so bad that they can spend $50 or $60 million on these movies? I can't wrap my head around it. newVideoPlayer("/The_Happening_Cough_Syrup.flv", 506, 423,""); Are we going to see any love for M. Night Shyamalan this year? It looks like it has the possibility, but if there's anything he's learned from the multiple Razzies that Lady in the Water won years ago, it's that casting yourself as a Jesus-like character in your own movie doesn't go over well. At least he isn't in The Happening. That was one that was a lot of fun to see with people when it first opened, because the audience doesn't know you're going to find out that it's bush—but not the President!—that's responsible for Armageddon. That twist he does in all his movies was particularly dunderheaded in this one. And I'm normally an admirer of Betty Buckley, but of all the elements in this movie that I hope get nominated, Betty Buckley as a crazy old lady who crashes her head through a window and screams at Mark Wahlberg is high on my list. That definitely deserves some attention from us!PREVIOUSLY: Razzie Nominations Serve A Shocking Snub To 'The Spirit'

Comment on this story
 
Read full story at defamer.com

In This Story

Related Content

The Spirit Misses Razzie Nomination By A Hair [Razzies]
The nominations for all of the worst movies of 2008 are out. And lucky, lucky Frank Miller missed the nominations for the worst movie in the history in the world by a few days.Unfortunately, The Spirit came out too late to make the Razzie nomination ballot, according to the site:ALTHOUGH IT FLOPPED TOO LATE to MAKE OUR NOMINATING BALLOT, WE THOUGHT ITS UNDER ACHIEVEMENTS EARNED IT a PLACE on OUR FORUM. Frank Miller is a lucky man, but I'm not going to forget the sins this movie committed that easily. See yo

“High School Musical 3” Receives a Razzie Award
A Razzie is one award you do not want to receive, but “High School Musical 3” and its stars are on the Razzie award list. Here’s the scoop: Worst Actor: Zac Efron, Dane Cook, Larry the Cable Guy, Eddie Murphy, Al Pacino, Keanu Reeves, Sylvester Stallone, Tom Cruise (Valkyrie), Will Ferrell, Ashton Kutcher, Mike Myers, Adam Sandler, Mark Wahlberg Worst Actress: Paris Hilton, Jessica Alba, The cast of ‘The Women,’ Camilla Belle, Cameron Diaz, Kate Hudson, Diane Keaton, Jen

2008 Razzie Nominating Ballot Calls Into Question Seriousness of Awards
The esteemed membership of the Razzie voting committee received their 2008 nominating ballots in the mail yesterday afternoon — and controversy abounds! While the official list of nominees for the year's worst movies and acting won't be released until January 21, the names on the ballot from which serious-minded voters are expected to choose are laughable at best.Never mind egregious omissions like Seven Pounds, the winner of Vulture's Critics' Poll for 2008's crappiest film, and The Spirit, which las

2008 Razzies Nominations Announced
I’m not a hige fan of the Academy Awards or any of those serious awards ceremonies if I’m honest. I know that’s probably not a good career move as a movie blogger but it’s the truth so what the hell. I just can’t get excited about giving awards to actors who have already been paid a huge amount of money to Star in the movies. It’s like they need even more praise and reward than they already get just for being a celebrity. So what I prefer is those spoof awards ceremonie

The Spirit Snubbed At The Razzies??
We posted the Razzies nominations so robotically yesterday we didn't even think of the films that could possibly get snubbed from the Razzies, the award ceremony that honors that most poorly made and insipid films of the year. After all, tracking the worst is pretty easy and the Razzies do a pretty good job each year.A lot of the obvious, usual deserving suspects were nominated, "Speed Racer," "The Love Guru," "The Day The Earth Stood Still," Keanu Reeves, Sylvester Stallone, Tom Cruise ("Valkyrie"), Ashton

Pick 2008's Worst Movies
Every year as Golden Globes are shined and Oscars are polished, there is one award that no celebrity is interested in receiving: The Golden Razzie, which goes to the year's worst movies and actors. Actually, I shouldn't say "no celebrity" since in 2005 Halle Berry awesomely ascended the stage to claim her worst actress prize for "Catwoman" - check out this clip of her reflecting on the moment. Anyhoo, this year's nominees have been released and, per usual, the choices are pretty spot on, although, Reese

Razzie Award Nominations - The Worst Movies and Performances of 2008
The 29th Annual Razzie Award Nominations have been released. For those who don’t know, the Razzies cellebrate the worst films and performances of the year. I’m surprised to see the hate for Rambo and Sylvester Stallone, which were nominated for Worst Picture, Worst Actor, Worst On Screen Couple (Sylvester Stallone & His Ego… very funny), Worst Director, Worst Sequel and Worst Career Achievement as a lot of my friends enjoyed that film. I’ve included my personal choices below in bold.

MSN produces surpringly somewhat accurate list on the year 2008
Maybe 2007 left us spoiled. With future classics like "Zodiac," "No Country for Old Men" and "There Will Be Blood" gracing our screens, 2008, so far, feels a little less ... significant. But that was on first glimpse; now that we've dug in and really looked back through the entire year, we can safely say (and the year's not over yet) that 2008 has been interesting, unexpected -- especially when it comes to performers.Comedians who are usually funny, like Mike Myers and Will Ferrell, were outshined by actors

New Tom Cruise Valkyrie Posters
Below from PosterGeek you can checkout a whole slew of new posters for Valkyrie. I have to say the first poster released months ago is by far the best ( its on the far right below ) In a country in the grips of evil, in a police state where every move is being watched, in a world where justice and honor have been subverted, a group of men hidden inside the highest reaches of power decide to take action. Based on the true story of Colonel Claus von Stauffenberg and the daring and ingenious plot

Tom Cruise speaks about Jett Travolta's death
Tom Cruise stopped by The View yesterday to promote his new film Valkyrie. He ended up speaking about the death of his fellow Scientologist John Travolta's son Jett, according to People:"I just don't have the words for it," says Cruise. "It's just horrific. Here you have a man, both of them doting parents, they're wonderful people and…" As for speculation that the Travoltas did not seek medical help for Jett, who had a history of seizures, because of their Scientology beliefs, Cruise, also a Scientologi

Tom Cruise Talks About Jett Travolta’s Death on The View
XHTML: You can use these tags: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong> -->

Tom Cruise, Reese Witherspoon On Razzie Ballots
LOS ANGELES, Calif. -- It's awards season and the ballots are out - for the Razzie Awards, the annual ceremony awarding the worst films and performances of the year. The nominee long lists for the 29th Annual Razzie Awards were released on Wednesday, and include such stars as Tom Cruise ("Valkyrie"), Mark Wahlberg and Keanu Reeves in the Worst Actor category and movies such as "Speed Racer," "High School Musical 3" and Paris Hilton's "The Hottie & The Nottie" for Worst Picture. Paris is up for W

People's Choice Award Winners
Favorite COMPETITION/REALITY SHOW Dancing with the StarsAmerican Idol Extreme Makeover:Home Edition Favorite GAME SHOW Deal or No Deal Are you Smarter than a 5th Grader? Jeopardy Favorite MALE TV STAR Hugh LaurieCharlie Sheen Patrick Dempsey Favorite FEMALE TV STAR Christina ApplegateMariska Hargitay Sally Field Favorite TALK SHOW HOST Ellen DeGeneresDavid Letterman Regis Philbin & Kelly Ripa Favorite SCENE STEALING GUEST STAR Robin Williams on Law & Order: SVUBritney Spears on How I Met Your Mother Luke Pe

Razzie Awards 2009 Nominations
The 29th Annual Razzie Awards have mailed out ballots containing the nominees for the worst films of 2008. Some nominations seem undeserved, but some others like “Disaster Movie,” “Rambo,” and “The Love Guru” are totally justified. I can understand nominations for Zac Efron, Sly Stallone and OH! Adam Sandler! Wait, where is Sandler’s “Zohan” at the list!? OK, but why Tom Cruise in “Valkyrie“? You can say he’s crazy, I mean

Joining the Razzie rampage
We might've joined up with the merry band of Razzie givers just to be among the sardonic crew that hands out "worst of" awards every year in the shadow of the Oscars.Or maybe because we had such a good time at the event last year. Oh, the laughs we had at LiLo's expense! But when we learned a few weeks back that the group planned to give out a new kudo -- a "career award," similar to a lifetime achievement, but, you know, the opposite -- we knew we were in. Uwe Boll,

Roger Friedman Gives Confusing, Contradictory Oscar Advice to Kate Winslet
Kate Winslet isn't making any bones about her unbridled lust for a certain Little Gold Man this year. First, she went on record with Vanity Fair as saying, "Do I want it? You bet your fucking ass I do!" before telling Britain's Reveal that "I want to win, I'm not denying that." And despite the fact that neither Revolutionary Road nor The Reader is getting any traction in the Best Picture race, there's still a good possibility that Winslet could see herself nominated in both the Best Actress and Best Support

The 2008 Razzie Nominations: Worst of the year in film
The 2008 Razzie Award nominations have been released, chronicling the year’s worst films and performances. There were so many stinkers to choose from - I’d bet it’s harder to pick the nominees for this than it is the Oscars and Golden Globes. This year’s big “winners” include the movie Speed Racer, which has topped many critics’ “Worst” lists, while frontrunners for worst actor/actress include Dane Cook, Larry the Cable Guy, Cameron Diaz and...

The Golden Raspberry Award Nominees
Movie hunks Tom Cruise, Mark Wahlberg and Keanu Reeves have been named and shamed on the ballot of this year's initial Golden Raspberry Award nominees. The trio is among those up for the Worst Actor dishonor at the Razzies ceremony on the eve of the Oscars. The ballot nominations, which were announced on Wednesday, also feature Meet the Spartans, Speed Racer , High School Musical 3, The Happening, Meet Dave and Paris Hilton's The Hottie & The Nottie as the Worst Film nods. Meanwhil

Tom Cruise on Jett Travolta's Death: "It's Just Horrific"
Tom Cruise echoed the world's sentiments as he spoke out on

The View January 9th Recap: Tom Cruise
Today on The View, in this episode that was taped Thursday, all five hosts were present. They were all wearing black and white and pretty dressy. Barbara said it was by accident, but Whoopi said subconsciously they all dressed up for guest Tom Cruise. A NY doctor is suing his ex-wife for a return of the kidney he donated to her or over $1 million in compensation. Sherri said he claims she cheated on him, but the alleged boyfriend denied any affair. Barbara wants to know how you set a price

Tom Cruise Eats Brad Pitt's Box Office Dust
Pitt Beats Cruise | The British Are Coming | How Kate Winslet Could Win An Oscar | More About Josh Brolin’s Broadway Debut | Prince Returns; Entertainment Weakly Pitt Beats Cruise At Box Office The numbers are in, and Brad Pitt has Tom Cruise beat at the box office. Of course, Pitt’s ex wife Jennifer Aniston has them both by wide margin, but that’s another story. All three stars released films on Christmas Day. But in t

Tom Cruise's Golden Globe Date? Katie's Dad!
Katie Holmes won't be walking the red carpet with Tom Cruise at Sunday's Golden Globes. Instead, Cruise -- who is up for best supporting actor for Tropic Thunder -- will be hitting the carpet with her father (and his mother) as Holmes performs her final run of All My Sons on Broadway. "Kate said, 'You go.'" he explained on Friday's The View, adding that he'll be with "her father and my mother." See...

Tom Cruise On Suri's Fame, Stage Hunger
Tom Cruise appeared on "The View" Friday for most of the hour. In addition to expressing strong condolences to the Travolta family during the interview, which taped on Thursday, he talked about daughter Suri. Elisabeth asked what he thinks of Suri's fame, and Cruise answered that he is torn. "It's both very flatteringly and you go, 'it is what it is.'" He then told a story about going to see Katie Holmes (30 times and counting) in her play "All My Sons. Recently he has sat with Suri on his lap in the wings

Tom Cruise Responds To Jett Travolta’s Death
John Travolta’s (sometimes) best bud and fellow church member Tom Cruise was taped earlier on an episode of The View, voicing his thoughts on the death of Jett Travolta…John and Kelly Preston’s 16-year-old son, who succumbed to injuries sustained inside the bathroom of a suite his family rented for the holidays. Jett’s death is also believed precipitated by a lifelong “mystery” seizure disorder.

Leave a Comment

Name

Email

Your Comment


Email me when comments are added

If you are commenting as a guest, enter your personal information in the form provided. Don't worry, your privacy is safe.

You can also login to your account or use one of the following methods:






© Copyright Celebrifi 2010