Best And Worst Science Fiction Movies Of 2008 [Io9 2008 Year In Review]

io9.com - 26th Dec 2008

1 votes

The Curious Case of Benjamin Button: This wasn't just the year that science fiction dominated the movies �” it also featured an amazing diversity of SF stories. Here's our list of the greatest �” and most horrendous �” films of 2008.Okay, so here are the movies that blew us away and horrified us this year:BEST:10. Let The Right One In. This intense, beautiful Swedish movie about a 12-year-old boy's relationship with a vampire did the near-impossible: it almost made us forget the blah Twilight. It's a parable of the world-destroying power of adolescence, that stays with you long afterwards.9. Teeth. This year saw a boomlet in feminist horror movies, between this film and Zombie Strippers. But the raw satire of vagina-dentata movie Teeth was sharper, and the story of how Dawn comes to realize her toothy mutant pussy is a superpower rather than a curse is a beautiful spin on adolescence. 8. Speed Racer. Pretty much everyone hates this movie except us �” Entertainment Weekly listed it twice on its year's worst lists, even as the mag praised the bland Benjamin Button. But we really did love this film, for its crazy, surreal CG vistas and fun follow-your-heart storyline. Racer was the last thing you'd expect from the Wachowskis: a film about family values, in which Speed learns that love for family trumps everything else. (And Susan Sarandon and John Goodman, as Speed's parents, pretty much run away with the film.) This movie is a cult classic waiting to happen.7. Cloverfield. Of all the movies on this year's "best" list, this is the one I can least imagine wanting to watch more than once. But that's okay, because the one time you watch it, you'll be blown away. At least in the theater, the movie's shaky-camcorder gimmick actually works: it's totally immersive, and you really follow these yuppie dorks as they fight their way through pubic lice and monster debris to save their friend. 6. Sleep Dealer. We called it one of the best small-budget science fiction movies in years, in our review back in October. Set in a future where Mexicans do menial labor in the U.S. via telepresence, Dealer is a commentary on immigration and racism. But it's also a brilliant thought experiment and a character piece. And it has the hottest cyberpunk node-installation scene since the flawed-but-fun Existenz.5. Iron Man. This movie exceeded our expectations, delivering a mind-expanding story of the military-industrial complex instead of just a superhero punch-em-up. I was so excited, I wrote a giant essay instead of a simple review.4. City Of Ember. It could have been just another young-people-discover-their-world-is-a-lie movie, but instead it becomes a post-apocalyptic masterpiece. Thanks to Martin Laing's gigantic sets and Gil Kenan's beautiful direction, the subterreanean city becomes a real place. You can actually feel the terror and claustrophobia when the lights start going out. And Bill Murray is in rare form as the corrupt, short-sighted mayor. 3. Synecdoche, NY. Charlie Kaufman gave us Being John Malkovitch and Eternal Sunshine Of The Spotless Mind, but this is probably his weirdest, most surreal movie. Caden (Philip Seymour Hoffman) is suffering from a weird, nonsensical ailment that is making his autonomic functions shut down, and meanwhile his daughter is turning into an anemic fetish model. So he creates an ambitious, incomprehensible work of art �” a recursive model of New York inside a New York warehouse, complete with actors playing real people. And it's a comedy. I laughed so hard at the stuff about Caden's therapist, and his attempts to make himself cry when his tearducts have shut down, I nearly choked on my popcorn.2. The Dark Knight. This movie got us so worked up, we reviewed it twice. Sure, it was too long �” and did the Joker really have to put explosives in the hospital and the boats? �” but its ambition pays off, in the end. The story of Harvey Dent's fall from grace is epic enough to support all of the movie's endless incidents and action set pieces. And we're still debating the movie's politics (Pro-torture? Pro-surveillance? Anti-hero? Nihilistic or just anarchic?) months later.1. Wall-E The only movie in years that I've wanted to watch again, right away. If I hadn't been starving and late for dinner, I would have watched it two or three times in one sitting. The first half hour, featuring the cute-bot in the post-apocalyptic abandoned Earth, is poetic and slapsticky. But then Wall-E gets into space, and it just gets crazier and more satirical, all without ever being mean or cheap. Plus it's a moving robot love story.Even though 2008 was a pretty awesome year for movies, I still ended up with way more candidates for the "worst" list than the "best" list, sadly. 1. Indiana Jones And The Kingdom Of The Crystal Skull. This is one of those movies that I was so-so about at the time, but it's gotten worse in my mind since then. Too much Shia, especially Shia of the Jungle. Criminally underused Karen Allen. Mostly, too much boring retreading of past Indy movies, and CG ants, and a totally crap alien head-melting ending. 2. Hancock. All we could think about were ways it could have sucked less. Like if it was really a comedy instead of a bland romp that turns melodramatic halfway through. It had one joke, and ran it into the ground like... like a drunken superhero who smashes into the asphalt when he flies. A couple of funny moments couldn't rescue this dud. 3. Doomsday. Actually, this one belongs on a special so-bad-it's-great list. You'll be getting drunk/stoned and watching this one on DVD long after most "good" movies are forgotten. Just for the cannibals who dance to Fine Young Cannibals, and Malcolm McDowell's SCA kingdom. Yes, it's pretty terrible, but in a wonderful way.4. X-Files: I Want To Believe. Wasn't this a show about people who investigate things? Apparently not, or at least the movie turned into a dull relationship drama. Bleh.5. Jumper. I liked the clips of the "jumpscar" special effect and the whole bus-attack thing, but it didn't make for much of a movie. Even with a script by David Goyer, the whole thing is underwhelming. You keep waiting and waiting for David (Hayden Christensen) to step up and become a hero �” or at least become interesting to watch �” and it never happens. 6. The Day The Earth Stood Still Unlike my colleague Nivair, I hadn't pre-judged this one. I really thought it could be a good film in its own right, even if it wasn't true to the original. I was horribly, eye-searingly wrong. It starts out great, but then Keanu goes on a boring road trip while droning about the environment and eating at Mickey D's. Giant robot Gort shows up here and there, but he can't stop the movie from standing still. 7. The Happening could have been an interesting film �” people start killing themselves in horrible ways, for no reason. But then it had to turn into a horror film about trees trying to destroy us, until they change their minds. People stare in horror and despair �” at trees. Ohh kay.8. Meet Dave. With a script by MST3K's Bill Corbett and a cool concept (a tiny guy lands on Earth in a human-sized spaceship that looks like him), this could have been a fun ride. Instead, it's a showcase for Eddie Murphy doing funny voices. 9. Space Chimps We got one great animated science fiction movie, so of course Hollywood had to punish us with an avalanche of drek. Including this horrific Andy Samberg vehicle about monkeys in space. Probably Fly Me To The Moon belongs on this "worst movies" list too, but none of us saw it. It was too soon after Chimps, and it just looked like pure torture. 10.The Spirit could have been sorta great too �” we love Will Eisner, and Frank Miller used to be one of the greats, 20 years ago. But Miller has turned into a self-parody, and he decided to go all-out with the crazy camp in this film. Weirdly, even though this film is a visual maelstrom and features an eyelinered Samuel L. Jackson dressing as a Nazi and torturing cats, the film's biggest problem is that it's boring. And then there were a lot of movies that were neither "best" nor "worst," they just were. Like, say, Incredible Hulk. It wasn't a great movie, it wasn't a terrible movie, it was just adequate. Call it "the credible Hulk." Or Death Race, which I couldn't bring myself to hate despite the lackluster third reel. Or Wanted, which was as dumb as ten piles of rocks but looked purty. Or Star Wars: Clone Wars, which was a fun, if forgettable, TV show, which got put on the big screen due to George Lucas' hubris. Read full story at io9.com

In This Story

The Curious Case of Benjamin Button

Eddie Murphy

Fine Young Cannibals

Andy Samberg

Gil Kenan

David Goyer

The Dark Knight

Related Content

Cash-Poor George Lucas Finally Sells Off Rights To 'Star Wars' Musical; 'Narnia' Dumped By Disney And More...
Where have we been? Taking a well deserved rest, that's where, but we're a little bored today, so we're coming out of the woodwork and from our self-imposed at-home movies marathon. Here's stuff that's been happening for the four-five days we've been offline.George Lucas has finally signed off on a "Star Wars" musical. He probably has a few less millions to play with because of the economy. Maybe we should start a paypal account for him. [E!Online] Apparently a "Star Wars" musical has been proposed several

'The Spirit,' 'Seven Pounds' and 'Revolutionary Road': A Taxonomy of Trash [Rants]
Though Hollywood reserves the holiday movie season for its annual harvest of ambition, prestige and clout, even the most painstaking Oscar husbandry can often fail. For three much-anticipated films in particular, the damage varies.So Bad it's Good:The Spirit (Dec. 25). Perhaps it's best to know as little as possible going into this adaptation of Will Eisner's classic 1940s comic series, written and directed by Eisner acolyte Frank Miller in the arresting visual style of his debut (with Robert Rodriguez) Sin

SAG ( SAG Awards) Nominations 2008 Announced
30 Rock and Mad Men have won the love of Emmy voters, the Hollywood Foreign Press Association and now their peers: The quirky comedy and advertising drama continued their streaks Thursday morning with three Screen Actors Guild nominations each.Alec Baldwin and Tina Fey will look to defend their SAG crowns in the male and female comedy categories, while the Rock cast looks for its first comedy ensemble statuette. The cast will face off against those of The Office, Desperate Housewives, Entourage and Weeds.Fo

Mark Wahlberg isn’t a fan of Saturday Night Live.
Mark Wahlberg is not so happy with the “Saturday Night Live” sketch from October 4th called “Mark Wahlberg Talks To Animals”. In Sunday’s NY Post, Mark Wahlberg has a Q&A to help promote his upcoming movie “Max Payne,” towards the end is asked what he thought of the skit. Andy Samberg plays Mark Wahlberg as he talks to a dog, a goat, a chicken and a donkey. It’s described on NBC’s website as “Barky Bark and the Donkey Bunch.” Sample dialo

THE SCREEN ACTORS GUILD AWARDS
Alan Rosenberg With Angela Bassett And Eric McCormack Make The AnnouncementsDoubt is the main leader at the upcoming Screen Actors Guild Awards, garnering five award nominations. The picture’s star, Meryl Streep, is competing for Outstanding Performance by a Female Actor in a Leading Role. She will go up against Angelina Jolie (Changeling), Anne Hathaway (Rachel Getting Married), Melissa Leo (Frozen River) and Kate Winslet (Revolutionary Road). Streep’s Doubt co-stars Amy Adams and Viola Davis will

The Actors Nominate Heath Ledger
The Screen Actors Guild (SAG) announced the nominations for the 15th Annual Screen Actors Guild Awards this morning and Heath Ledger received a nomination for supporting actor in The Dark Knight . He is up against Josh Brolin for Milk , Robert Downey Jr. for Tropic Thunder , Philip Seymour Hoffman for Doubt and Dev Patel for Slumdog Millionaire . In the Stunt Ensemble category, four superhero movies were nominated, including The Dark Knight , Hellboy II: The Golden Army , Iron Man and Wanted . T

A Frank Miller Western? ‘The Spirit’ Co-Stars Scarlett Johansson & Samuel L. Jackson Tease ‘Sin City 2’ And Mystery Project
T-minus two days and counting until “The Spirit” hits theaters, and Splash Page couldn’t be more excited to see Will Eisner’s classic comic character make the leap from pulp to cinema. However, when “The Spirit” co-stars Scarlett Johansson and Samuel L. Jackson recently sat down for a chat with MTV’s Joshua Horowitz, the conversation just so happened to shift to another, highly-anticipated Frank Miller vehicle, “Sin City 2,” as well as a diff

‘Batman 3’ Casting Rumor Denied By Eddie Murphy, Won’t Play The Riddler In ‘Dark Knight’ Sequel
While the British writer who reported that Eddie Murphy would play The Riddler is sticking by his story, Murphy himself has now denied the casting rumor — or rather, one of his representatives has denied it on his behalf. According to Access Hollywood, a representative of Murphy has categorized the rumors as “not true.” So, where does that leave us in the “Batman 3” rumor mess? The initial British report that cast Murphy in the role also attached Shia LaBeouf as

‘Eddie Murphy As Riddler’ Reporter Sticks By ‘Dark Knight’ Sequel Casting Rumors
FROM SPLASH PAGE: Sure, we all had a good laugh at the expense of the U.K.-based tabloid The Sun after they announced that Eddie Murphy and Shia LaBeouf would portray The Riddler and Robin, respectively, in “Gotham” (what The Sun claimed to be the title of the follow-up to this summer’s “The Dark Knight”). After all — as we’ve made perfectly clear — Warner Bros., director Christopher Nolan and various high-level execs attached to the franchise have

Cue the Ewoks, Star Wars Hits the Stage (E! Online)
Not content with seven feature films or myriad TV spinoffs ranging from the current Clone Wars cartoon series to the dreaded Star Wars Holiday Special, the Jedi masterminds are readying a stage show. George Lucas has signed off on Star Wars: A Musical Journey, a two-hour live musical event featuring a Stormtrooper kick line and singing Wookiees John Williams' Oscar-winning score. Premiering next year in London's O2 arena, the produ

Broke George Lucas Sells Off 'Star Wars' Stage Musical [The End Of Ideas]
On the same day a Vanity Fair writer delivered the definitive history of the worst Star Wars spinoff ever, another report suggests that infamous show may soon have competition.E! notes today that George Lucas has sold his blessing to Star Wars: A Musical Journey, which will premiere next year in London with the Royal Philharmonic Orchestra providing accompaniment to series excerpts screened in chronological order — from The Phantom Menace to Return of the Jedi. The bad news: No Clone Wars, and thus no

Check Out ‘The Spirit’ iPhone Application!
On behalf of Lionsgate, we are pleased to present The Spirit iPhone Application which enables tech savvy fans of the cult graphic artist/film director, Frank Miller, to see themselves depicted in the directors’ iconic style made popular in “300” and “Sin City”. iPhone users are able to access content from the film and replace the stars of THE SPIRIT – Samuel L. Jackson, Scarlett Johansson, Eva Mendes, Jamie King and Gabriel Macht – with their own 3-D images.

What Kind of Year Has it Been: Dan's Top 5 of 2008
Now, normally an end of year top 10 list would be in order, but honestly, a trip to the cinema these days seems less and less enticing. Fond memories of seeing The Fellowship of the Ring for the first time, or sneaking into Kill Bill Part 1, or further back the re-release of the Star Wars Trilogy in theaters seem distant now. Many films aim to do nothing but make enough barely amusing ads (in the case of a comedy) or stupidly grand ones (in the case of action) to get the butts in the seats, then distra

'Flight Of The Red Balloon' Tops IndieWire's Poll Of 100 Critics
Man, who would have thought? Hou Hsiao-hsien's "Flight Of The Red Balloon" top IndieWire's Poll of 100 North American critics as the Best Film Of 2008. We're not sure what other widespread poll asks 100 critics for its picks, but that's a pretty substantial number and nothing to scoff at. Arnaud Desplechin's "A Christmas Tale," came in second. And populist fare like "Wall-E" ranked well above something supposedly more indie-friendly than "The Wrestler."We'll be totally honest. We never saw 'Red Balloon. One

The SAG noms are…
Outstanding Performance by a Male Actor in a Leading RoleRICHARD JENKINS / Walter Vale - “THE VISITOR” (Overture Films) Frank Langella / Richard Nixon - “FROST/NIXON” (Universal Pictures) Sean Penn / Harvey Milk - “MILK” (Focus Features) Brad Pitt / Benjamin Button - “The Curious Case of Benjamin Button” (Paramount Pictures) Mickey Rourke / Randy - “THE WRESTLER” (Fox Searchlight Pictures)Outstanding Performance by a Female Actor in a Leading Role

'The Spirit' is thrilling, but some characters are weak
Comic book movies tend to be summer fare. While Iron Man and TheDark Knight were this year's hot-weather highlights, The Spirit, in its dark artiness, works well during this chillier season. Based on the comic books by Will Eisner and written and directed by Frank Miller, it resembles Sin City, which Miller co-directed, and Miller's comic series 300. With its dark palette and stylized look, it also incorporates an evocative film noir style. Some performances are particularly fun, such as Samu

Bid on Spirit posters signed by Scarlett Johansson, Eva Mendes and Samuel L. Jackson to benefit Elisabeth Glaser Pediatric Aids foundation!
eBay charitable auctions for five posters from "THE SPIRIT” signed by Frank Miller, Eva Mendes, Scarlet Johansson, Gabriel Macht, Samuel L. Jackson and Dan Lauria, plus an additional sixth poster package that includes a cast signed poster, THE SPIRIT snow globe, THE SPIRIT action figure and THE SPIRIT coffee table book. All the proceeds will benefit the The Elizabeth Glaser Pediatric AIDS Foundation. All items will be sent with a signed letter verifying their authenticity. Auctions begin today and will

James Martsers joins Star Wars - but not as Anakin Skywalker
Filed under: Other Sci-Fi/Supernatural Shows, Casting, Reality-FreeIn an interview with StarWars.com (yeah, I go there) former Buffy the Vampire Slayer baddie James Marsters talks about his new character, Captain Argyus, who he voices on tonight's ep of Star Wars: The Clone Wars. But, here's the interesting news: Marsters says George Lucas once considered him for the role of Anakin Skywalker for the Star Wars prequel films. "When George Lucas was casting The Phantom Menace he, for one day maybe, considered

SAG Awards 2009: The Complete Nominations List
Check out the full list here! THEATRICAL MOTION PICTURESOutstanding Performance by a Male Actor in a Leading RoleRICHARD JENKINS / Walter Vale - "THE VISITOR" (Overture Films)Frank Langella / Richard Nixon - "FROST/NIXON" (Universal Pictures)Sean Penn / Harvey Milk - "MILK" (Focus Features)Brad Pitt / Benjamin Button - "The Curious Case of Benjamin Button" (Paramount Pictures)Mickey Rourke / Randy - "THE WRESTLER" (Fox Searchlight Pictures)Outstanding Perfo

The Evil, the Bad and the (Self-)Important
When she put "The Boy in the Striped Pajamas" on her Worst Movies of 2008 list, Entertainment Weekly's Lisa Schwartzbaum referred to the Holocaust melodrama as "Honey, I Gassed the Kids." And, if she honestly believes the movie is as awful as she describes it (and I have no reason to think she doesn't), it is her moral duty as a critic to pummel it with everything she's got. A "dumb summer comedy" can be awful, undendurable; an irresponsible or simpleminded film that exploits and trivializes a "powerful

The Rocchi Review with Kris Tapley of In Contention
Which year-end lists are really worth caring about? What films got a boost from the Broadcast Film Critics and Golden Globe nominations, like Happy-Go-Lucky, and which ones got lost in the shuffle? What's Iron Man doing on the AFI Top Ten Films List, anyhow? And what long, epic films are perfect for enjoying with a turkey sandwich on Boxing Day? Joining James this week to talk about all these topics and more is Kris Tapley of the weblog In Contention. You can listen to the podcast here at Cinema

Full-Length Monsters Vs. Aliens Trailer Unveiled!
Take a look at the new trailer from the DreamWorks Animation action comedy.The Cast of The Spirit Speaks! Gabriel Macht, Eva Mendes, Scarlett Johansson and Samuel L. Jackson break down their work on this new film from Frank Miller.Star Trek to Complete Post Production Next Week Director J.J. Abrams updates fans on film's production status.Get Your First Look at G-Force We've got a sneak peek at this Jerry Bruckheimer produced film.Clive Owen Is Going to Cartagena Movie to be made through Mark Cu

Watchmen Director Zack Snyder Wants to Direct "The Dark Knight Returns"
Zack Snyder's Christmas wish is to adapt Frank Miller's comic book "The Dark Knight Returns" into a feature film. Snyder, who is helming the upcoming comic book movie Watchmen, told iFMagazine that he has asked studio Warner Bros about creating a big screen adaptation of the classic comic, which focuses on an aged Batman/Bruce Wayne who comes out of retirement to defend Gotham City for a final time. "I said I'm interested in Frank Mil

The Han Solo Comedy Hour!
Wookiees and Bea Arthur? Luke Skywalker and Harvey Korman? Singing and dancing and storm troopers? If George Lucas had his way, no one would remember, but yes, Virginia, there was a Star Wars Holiday Special.

Best And Worst Science Fiction Movies Of 2008 [Io9 2008 Year In Review]

In This Story

The Celebrifi Network

About Us

Privacy Policy

Terms of Service

Contact Us

Newsroom